Skip to content
May 28, 2025
  • Ms. Marvel goes on a Giant-Size X-Men adventure in this week’s CXF Staff Picks
  • We understand the flashbacks now in Amazing Spider-Man #3-4 (Plus: Spider-Man & Wolverine)
  • Deadpool, Batman to team up in Marvel and DC’s first intercompany crossover in decades
  • The 10 best X-Men time travel stories according to the Battle of the Atom podcast 

COMICSXF

The comics criticism you crave

  • HOME
  • Articles
    • Opinions
    • Issue Overviews
    • Television Overviews
    • Interviews
    • Odds & Ends
    • Redesigning
  • Battle of The Atom
  • TCXFIP
  • BatChat
  • Primer
    • Creator Primers
    • The Pull List
    • Character Primers
    • Team Primers
  • Patreon
  • Shop
  • About Us
  • Home
  • 2021
  • October

October 2021

  • Opinions

Sunday Editorial: X-Men and the Fine Art of Treading Water

Austin Gorton4 years ago4 years ago012 mins

The following first appeared in the ComicsXF newsletter. You can get early access to our editorials, a roundup of the week’s best content and get to know the members of the ComicsXFamily by subscribing right here. In recent weeks, there’s been mild outrage and teeth-gnashing in some corners of the X-Men social media sphere over the…

Read More
  • Redesigning

Redesigning Madelyne Pryor

Josh Cornillon4 years ago3 years ago020 mins

Have you heard the sad, sad story of Madelyne Pryor? A mother, a pilot, a clone, and a Goblin Queen, Madelyne Pryor has lived many lives in her short time as a mainstay of the X-Men franchise. First appearing in Chris Claremont and Paul Smith’s Uncanny X-Men #168, Madelyne’s mystery and tragedy would come to…

Read More
  • Ice Cream Man

Dig into the Roots of Your Family — and Your Troubles — in Ice Cream Man #26

Will Nevin and Ari Bard4 years ago4 years ago011 mins

Are you brave enough to climb down the twisting, gnarled trunk of your family tree? And honest enough to accept whatever you find? Discover those internal truths and more in Ice Cream Man #26, written by W. Maxwell Prince, drawn by Martin Morazzo, colored by Chris O’Halloran and lettered by Good Old Neon. Will Nevin:…

Read More
  • DC

Watching Your Favorite Heroes Get Killed Couldn’t Be More Fun in DC vs. Vampires #1

Ari Bard and Ritesh Babu4 years ago4 years ago018 mins

Ari: Alrighty, let’s take a stroll through yet another DC alternate universe where a lot of heroes die, this time featuring vampires and the creative team of Matthew Rosenberg, James Tynion IV, Otto Schmidt and Tom Napolitano in DC vs. Vampires #1. Ritesh: I’m glad you mentioned this, because this is certainly part of that…

Read More
  • Batman

Let’s Hang out in the Sewers with Batman in This Week’s BatChat (Text Edition)

Matthew Lazorwitz and Will Nevin4 years ago4 years ago020 mins

Welcome back to BatChat! In Detective Comics #1,044, Batman must save Mayor Nakano from the children of Vile while another Bat family member steps in to fight (the seized) City Hall in a story written by Mariko Tamaki, drawn by Dan Mora, colored by Jordie Bellaire and lettered by Aditya Bidikar. In the backup, a…

Read More
  • Daredevil

Caught in a Bad Romance in Daredevil #35

Anna Peppard4 years ago4 years ago029 mins

Bonds are rekindled and scripts are flipped in Daredevil #35. Written by Chip Zdarsky, drawn by Stefano Landini and Francesco Mobili, colored by Marcio Menyz, and lettered by Clayton Cowles, Daredevil #35, part 5 of “Lockdown,” sees heroes getting help and villains getting themselves into new, old, and romantic forms of trouble.  Writing reviews of…

Read More
Wolverine #17
  • Wolverine

Wolverine #17: You and What Arm-y?

Tony Thornley and Pierce Lightning4 years ago4 years ago012 mins

Wolverine #17: we’re up in arms about it! Maverick is back to team up with Wolverine. The crew does some karaoke and oh yah, some fighting.

Read More
Red Rain Banner
  • BatChat

BatChat With Matt & Will Ep. 6: Spooky Books- The BatChat Marry/F***/Kill Episode

Matthew Lazorwitz and Will Nevin4 years ago4 years ago02 mins

Just in time for Halloween, BatChat takes on three tales of Batman mixing it up with the supernatural. We have vampires, we have immortals, we have werewolves, and we have the scariest thing of all: a new worst story on the list! Listen in to hear what story it is, and hear Matt get so…

Read More
Darth Vader #17 Cover Banner
  • Star Wars

Darth Vader #17 Reveals a Traitor in Vader’s Midst

Austin Gorton4 years ago4 years ago011 mins

Vader deals with one betrayal while another is revealed in Star Wars: Darth Vader #17 written by Greg Pak, art by Raffele Ienco, colored by Alex Sinclair and lettered by Joe Caramagna. The series’ involvement in the “War of the Bounty Hunters” comes to a close this issue, and while that conclusion may feel a…

Read More
The Quiet Council
  • Uncategorized

X Observations About The New Quiet Council

Nola Pfau4 years ago4 years ago016 mins

In our earlier discussion regarding Inferno #2, Chris and I spent a little bit of time talking about new Quiet Council dynamics, but I really just couldn’t stop thinking about it. Here are some interesting things I noticed now that the Quiet Council is once again operating at full capacity. First, a quick breakdown of…

Read More
  • Black Hammer

A Mother’s Rage Unleashed in Dark Horse’s Black Hammer: Reborn #5

Mark Turetsky4 years ago4 years ago07 mins

A multidimensional nightmare wreaks chaos on Spiral City as the powerful superhero known as the Black Hammer joins forces with the brutal vigilante known as the Skulldigger to put an end to this madness in Black Hammer: Reborn #5, written by Jeff Lemire, drawn by Malachi Ward, Matthew Sheean and Rich Tomasso, and lettered by…

Read More
  • S.W.O.R.D.

ORCHIS Strikes Against Arakko In SWORD #9

Lex Smith and Nola Pfau4 years ago4 years ago028 mins

A traitor in the midst of S.W.O.R.D. as the Shi’Ar visit Arakko in SWORD #9 by Al Ewing, Jacopo Camagni, Fernando Sifuentes and Ariana Maher. Nola Pfau: Corey, did you know that, when using discussion format, the first instance of text should include the writer’s full first name? Corey Smith: I’d heard rumors, Nola, but…

Read More
  • Marauders

Lost In Space in Marauders #25

Stephanie Burt and Ian Gregory4 years ago4 years ago022 mins

Last time out in this Star Wars comic Marauders, our heroes sold a Macguffin to the dastardly double-crossing space criminal Eden Rixlo in exchange for his spaceship, and then he stole it back from them and shot them out the airlock. Can they come back from that? Marauders #25, writing by Gerry Duggan, art by…

Read More
  • Vault

Saddle up for Yukon Horrors in Vault’s THE RUSH #1

Forrest Hollingsworth and Zachary Jenkins4 years ago4 years ago019 mins

1899, Yukon Territory. A frozen frontier, bloodied and bruised by the last great Gold Rush. But in the lawless wastes to the north, something whispers in the hindbrains of men, drawing them to a blighted valley, where giant spidertracks mark the snow and impossible guns roar in the night. To Brokehoof, where gold and blood…

Read More
  • Uncategorized

The Quiet Council Embraces Its Destiny In Inferno #2

Chris Eddleman and Nola Pfau4 years ago4 years ago028 mins

The Reign Of X comes to a close as the Quiet Council expands. Enemies, allies, they are all the same in this dangerous game. Jonathan Hickman, Stefano Caselli, David Curiel and Joe Sabino bring us Inferno #2. Chris Eddleman: Well friends, it’s time again for a dive into the fire as we continue our coverage…

Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • …
  • 6
2016-2025, ComicsXF Powered By BlazeThemes.