The mysterious Captain Vadic gives Picard and the crew of the Titan an ultimatum: turn over Jack Crusher or die. Meanwhile, Raffi canāt āDisengageā from her obsessions in Picard Season 3 episode 2, written by Christopher Monfette & Sean Tretta and directed by Doug Aarniokoski.
Will Nevin: Hey, Mark, lemme ask you this: Letās say you were married, right? And you have a child with your partner. The kid is smart but super annoying, but thatās not really the point. Anyway, your partner dies (sorry!) and at some point, you have a super secret second child with your partnerās best friendā¦but you name the new kid after your partner.
Thatād be kinda weird, right?
Mark Turetsky: Of course notā¦ unless said best friend were somehow responsible for my late partnerās death. Now that would be weird. But this is such a strangely specific theoretical, Will. I canāt imagine where you come up with these things.
Will: Iām easily bored.
And Iāve also just watched episode 2 of the third season of Picard! Jean-Luc is a daddy!
For real.
We think.
Jack Crusher, Consummate Rogue
Mark: While last weekās episode opened with āI Donāt Want to Set The World On Fireā by The Ink Spots, this weekās episode starts with āStarchildā by the largely forgotten band Baby. While I can possibly think that Jean Lucās mix tape for Beverly included The Ink Spots, I think Baby is not within Picardās musical bailiwick. Still, āstar child?ā ābaby?ā I think the showās musical director is having some fun with us with this selection.
Will: I miss the days when the future only had royalty-free music ā but I suppose with all of the ties weāve seen to First Contact (which memorably used Steppenwolfās āMagic Carpet Rideā) itās only fitting. I tell ya, Mark, the first ten or so minutes of this episode were a slog, with a flashback to two weeks ago followed by picking up the action in what amounted to a recap, after we had already seen a recap. A bit boring there ā and I donāt think ābabyā Jack Crusherās charms made up for it.
Mark: Heās Han Solo with twice the heart and half the charisma.
Still, you canāt blame a man for not being Harrison Ford. I thought actor Ed Speleers did an okay job with what was ultimately a somewhat clichĆ© scene. It establishes heās a scoundrel, an outlaw, out on the edges of space trying to do some good in a cold, indifferent galaxy. The thing that really bugged me about this scene is, where was Beverly in all of this? I suppose they kept her off the board just so that they could leave some doubt in the audienceās mind as to whether heās really her son. After all, heās a liar and a scoundrel, and we only have it on his word that sheās his mother, right? Still, it seemed pretty clear in the opening last week that the Eleos is her ship, and she has all of the command level clearances, so where was she?
Will: Literally (albeit temporarily) fridged! It was one more contrivance to, as you said, keep her off the board for a critical scene that weāll get to later. For all of the talk of giving the cast members more to do, these first two episodes havenāt done a damned thing for anyone but Riker, who was pushed to the side in this episode and used for a handful of one-liners.
Mark: We also get a little hint as to who these particular Fenris Rangers work for when their leader mentions telling āthe Marked Womanā that theyāve found Jack Crusher. As Jack tells Picard and Riker back in the present, their enemies have taken on many identities, including Klingons and Starfleet personnel. But the ship thatās menacing the Eleos is none of those things. We talked a little bit about this outside of our reviews, but do you think we might be dealing with the āConspiracyā parasites? That episode is certainly a highlight of The Next Generation’s lackluster first season, and seemed like it was primed to become an ongoing story, but it just kinda fizzled out.
Will: We have to talk about something around the CXF office, right? Right now, if you squint the right way, it makes sense: Jack says all of these various factions are after him, and as we saw in āConspiracy,ā the bugs do have a leader/central mouthpiece, which could be Vadic. But I still think itās a reach. While āConspiracyā is dangling out there like a mealworm trying to squirm out of your mouth, I donāt think itās something theyād go back to, if only because it doesnāt feel epic enough.
Mark: Not epic enough?! Look at these kicks!
āConspiracyā has been followed up numerous times in comics, novels, and video games. Itās clearly something that TNG obsessives love to go back to. And it seems like itās those types who are running the ship now.
Anyway, the gang on the Eleos have reached a stalemate: Picard has installed transporter scramblers to keep anyone from beaming off the ship, and the unseen enemies tip their hand by trying to beam Jack, specifically Jack, off the ship. I guess I was right about Beverly trying to protect him by locking him away at the start of episode 1.
Will: Jack ā and presumably Beverly as well ā know more than theyāre letting on, but thatās what I suppose the other eight episodes are for. I know I said the beginning of the episode moved slowly, but even the confrontation with Vadicās ship crawled along. This is no longer a tight 44 minutes, and thereās more than a bit lost here because, again, we have to come up with contrivances to stretch this out into an episode. Why did Vadic give them an hour to comply? Because thatās what the episode needed.
Standoff At The Edge of Civilized Space!
Mark: Well, since weāre moving on to the introduction of our big baddie, letās stop and talk about Vadic for a bit.
Sheās played by Honey Bunny herself, Amanda Plummer, who seems to be relishing the taste of the scenery. Like many of Trekās greatest villains, sheās opted to play things big. And from her first communication with the Titanās bridge, she seems to know an awful lot about them. She knows about some secret in Captain Shawās past that nearly rendered him psychologically unfit for service. We can chalk up her knowledge of that to looking up info, albeit top secret, on the Titan before engaging with them, but she also knows Picard by sight, knows that heās a synth, which I donāt think is public knowledge. She certainly seems to know an awful lot. And maybe knows a thing or two about Jack Crusher that we donāt yet.
Will: Vadic better have some kind of interesting backstory ā like sheās a bug queen or something ābecause this trope of a big nasty villain showing up, chewing the scenery and having the time of their lives is getting old. This isnāt Batman ā66. Itās novel when Ricardo MontalbĆ”n does it, but we just saw this last year with Dr. Aspen in Strange New Worlds. Iām tired and cranky, Mark.
Mark: Youāll perhaps be interested, then, in Charlie Jane Andersā recent essay, ā7 Hot Takes About Star Trek,ā the first of which is that Trek is most interesting when the Federation is pitted against an ideological foil, rather than a singular villainous personality. We donāt really know anything about Vadic or the aliens of her crew, at least not yet. Iām also hoping we get some good motivation for her, but I for one am enjoying her performance so far. Iām a man of the theater at heart.
Will: Plummer is playing to the back row for sure. If they ever get brave enough to put me in charge of Trek, weāre making more stories about the politics of the galaxy falling apart rather than the enemies of the Federation tearing it asunder. No big, bad superweapons. Just plots designed to keep people in forever war and our heroes fighting back against that using their handsome looks and smart brains. Weāre going to keep making Undiscovered Country is what I’m saying.
Mark: I feel it is my duty to once again beg you to watch Deep Space Nine. [Ed. Note: I concur.]
Will: If Iām gonna watch Star Trek, it better have a shipās name in the title. Or something. One day. I promise.
So what do we make of Shaw here? He goes from hardass to super hardass to prideful, egotistical hardass to someone who meekly gives Picard the conn by the end of the episode.
Mark: Once again, I canāt help but identify with him. These two senior officers tried to commandeer his ship, giving him a flimsy excuse. They turned his first officer against him (though, yes, he certainly did quite a bit for that on his own, including his insistence on deadnaming her). Had they maybe told him about their friend in distress, he might have listened. Probably not, but heād be more sympathetic. As for his reluctant capitulation to Picardās wishes by the end, maybe itās related to his unnamed past trauma? Maybe he lost his own child to the Borg or something. Or maybe heās come to the realization that, despite his best efforts, heās found himself in a Star Trek.
Will: James_Cromwell.gif
Weāve both had our issues with this series ā hell, even this episode ā but when it can rise above itself and deliver on its promise and potential, itās an absolute home run. That moment when Beverly ā who can barely stand and is being assisted by Riker ā comes to the bridge and looks at Jean-Luc as heās ready to give up. That one moment, that one look that says, āHeās your son,ā confirming what Picard was not ready to admit? Fucking magic.
Mark: Itās a good moment, and Iām sure it took a lot of restraint not to give one of their āspecial guest starsā a single line, even if it was to knowingly say āJean-Luc.ā We also have the wonderful moment of Riker basically telling him, ādo I have to draw you a map?ā as to his willful blindness to Jackās parentage.
Will: Riker: āYou and Beverly fucked, right?ā (not really a line, but it felt like one) And then he actually, literally said, āDo the math.ā Incredible.
Mark: Thereās been a lot of speculation about when Beverly gave birth to Jack. Speleers is 34 years old, which would put him on the old side of playing a 20-year-old (as mentioned last week, thatās how long itās been since Picard saw Beverly). Itās not unheard of, but Iāve seen a lot of speculation online about the possibility that she had him while she was away during season 2 of TNG, when McFadden temporarily quit the show.
But my personal pet theory is that she had him during season 4, when McFadden herself was quite visibly pregnant, and the production hid this by making her blue lab coat bigger and bigger to hide the pregnancy.
Permit me, if you will: what if you were pregnant, visibly so, and nobody, not your crewmates, your best friends, nobody ever commented on it? Wouldnāt you send the child away for their own safety amongst this strange and alienating crew of people?
And then there are the scenes between Patrick Stewart and Speleers in the brig. Picard, as a rule, loves passing judgment and yelling at younger versions of himself, doesnāt he? The way Stewart plays it, seeing and yet denying Jackās similarity to his own wild youth, I thought those scenes were quite good. And Speleersā bitter accusation that he never had a father. Quite well done. Do we think that Jack knows?
Will: Jack has to, right? Or he knows what his mother told him. Gosh darn Carol Marcus and Jim Kirk all over again over again. Does that mean Jack is going to die? I donāt think Iād be against it.
In Too Deep
Mark: We return, with Raffi, to the drug-riddled demimonde of MāTalas Prime after her mysterious handler called her off the case. Starfleet blames the terrorist attack on a Romulan terrorist named Lurak TāLuco, having been tipped off by a legitimate Ferengi businessman named Sneed. Raffi, of course, doesnāt buy it, and reaches out to her only connection to Sneed, her ex-husband Jae Hwang.
Will: Iām still struggling with the writing on this plot. We donāt know where the recruitment center was, but apparently picking up and dropping what looked to be a big building will only kill 117 people. āFrontier Dayā was not even mentioned in this episode, so there goes that as some sort of plot driver. And of all the people in the galaxy who could be Raffiās less-than-helpful handler, it was Worf. That was a surprise, but Iām not sure it was a good one.
Mark: I should have realized it immediately when he called her a warrior last week (I was hoping for a real curveball and putting my money on it being Lore), but he really overdid it on the Klingon platitudes this time around.
Look, they need to tie in the rest of the TNG gang, and Iāve no doubt that Raffiās story is going to tie in with Picardās, so why not make it Worf? I was just listening to a podcast recently about the Street Fighter movie, and how Capcom insisted that it include every single playable Street Fighter character, which meant that every minor role in the movie had to become one of them. Now, a ten episode prestige TV drama has more room than a 102 minute action movie, but with the decompressed pace of storytelling weāre dealing with, itās a limitation of the production. And while the fact of Worfās appearance as Raffiās handler rankles me as well, it sure was a fun sequence when he showed up, wasnāt it?
Will: Worf slicing and dicing will never not be fun, but I donāt know how theyāll square that with what weāve seen of his character in the trailers. I hope the next three or four episodes wonāt be just this ā picking up legacy characters one at a time while the plot moves incrementally forward. Last week had me excited for the next episode. This one? Iām not sure.
Mark: Importantly, Raffi crosses two lines in this episode: picking the mission over seeing her son again and taking the drugs that Sneed offered her. That happened faster than I thought it would. What is it with sci-fi drugs administered to the eyes lately?
Will: At least it wasnāt a needle. That would have been icky. And it was another form of picking the mission over herself, right? A hard choice that was rendered instantly impotent when Sneed said he could see through her cover from the beginning. Iām not emotionally invested in her character or her plight at all. Recovery is a serious topic, and while I donāt think the show is handling it poorly, theyāre not exactly treating it with the time and care it deserves. (See Raffiās sacrifice being negated immediately.)
Mark: I canāt help but feel Raffi and her plight have taken a back seat, care-wise, to bringing back the TNG gang. Michelle Hurd is a wonderful actress, and Musiker has a ton of storytelling potential, but her journey is getting the short shrift here, even if it is the main b-plot of both episodes so far.
Will: Itās obviously going to tie into the a-story, so Iād advise them to get on with it. This show doesnāt need to drag anymore than it already does.
Make It So On and So Forth
- RIP, Shuttlecraft Saavik, likely named in memory of the late Kirstie Alley.
- āShe threw a ship at usā will never not be great.
- We didnāt talk about this last week, but the end credits (LCARS graphics + First Contact theme) is a great package.
- Worfās introduction used Goldsmithās Klingon theme from Star Trek: The Motion Picture. Along with his First Contact and The Motion Picture themes showing up in the main title sequence, this is a real musical love note to the composer.
- Jack calls the leader of the Fenris Rangers boarding party āmon ami.ā Another not-too-subtle hint that heās Picardās son?
- Sneed drinks Slug-o-Cola, the slimiest cola in the galaxy!
- The baseball in Sneedās collection. Could it possibly once have belonged to Captain Benjamin Sisko, emissary of The Prophets?